King Solomon asked God for wisdom and, if you believe the book, he got more of it than anyone before or since. Most people know the story about the baby. Two women both say the child is theirs, Solomon calls for a sword to cut it in half, and the woman who begs him to give the baby to the other one is obviously the mother. It has been the standard example of good judgment for about three thousand years.
What people tend to skip is how his own life went. He had seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines, he built altars to the gods his foreign wives worshipped, and he worked his people so hard that the northern tribes walked away as soon as his son was crowned. The man everyone came to for rulings couldn’t sort out his own house.
I’d bet you do a smaller version of this all the time, I know I do. A friend calls about a business partner who keeps missing deadlines and you know what to tell him before he’s finished talking. Sit down with the guy, write down what’s expected and give it a date. Then you hang up and go back to the situation you’ve been avoiding since spring. It isn’t that you’re not smart enough to see it. Psychologists have tested this and given it a name - the Solomon’s Paradox.
The Research
Igor Grossmann (Waterloo) and Ethan Kross (Michigan) published the study in 2014 and called the effect Solomon’s paradox, meaning we reason better about other people’s social problems than about our own. Across three experiments and 693 people, the ones thinking about someone else’s problem did better on the things researchers use to score wise reasoning: admitting what they didn’t know, looking for a compromise, expecting things to change and considering the other side. They didn’t make it easy either. Some participants were asked to imagine their own partner cheating on them and others a friend’s partner.
The part I found most uncomfortable was the age result. Older people did no better than younger ones when the conflict was personal. Kross’s point was that older adults might give better advice to others, but it doesn’t carry over when the decision is their own. So waiting until you’ve got more miles on the clock isn’t a plan.
What did work was getting some distance. When people looked at their own conflict the way a friend would, the gap went away and they reasoned about as well as they did for someone else.
Grossmann came back to this in 2021 with something you could actually do at home. People kept a diary for a month about the most significant thing that happened each day. One group wrote in the first person and the other wrote about themselves in the third, so an entry might ask why [their name] was feeling or acting the way they were. By the end of the month the third-person group scored higher on wise reasoning, mostly on intellectual humility and on taking other people’s views into account, while the first-person group hadn’t changed much. That tells me wisdom has as much to do with where you’re standing as with who you are.
How People Usually Handle It
When we’re stuck most of us do one of three things. We think harder, which usually means lying awake at 2 a.m. going over it in the first person, and that mostly makes us more anxious. We ask friends, who love us and can tell which answer we’re hoping for, and then we hear what they say through the same ego that got us stuck. Or we wait for things to become clear, which they rarely do while you’re still standing in the middle of them.
Intel, 1985
The best example I know of someone getting out of this trap is Andy Grove at Intel. By 1985 the memory chip business Intel had more or less invented was losing money, because Japanese manufacturers had turned it into a commodity. Grove and Gordon Moore had been talking themselves in circles about it for weeks. Then Grove asked Moore, “If we got kicked out and the board brought in a new CEO, what do you think he would do?” Moore said straight away that a new CEO would get out of memory. Grove’s response was that the two of them should walk out the door, come back in and do it themselves.
It wasn’t painless. Grove closed the memory business and about 7,000 people, close to a third of the company, lost their jobs. It’s also the decision that set Intel up for the next thirty years. Nothing about the facts had changed in that room. Grove just started looking at the problem the way his replacement would.
What I’d Actually Do
Start by writing the problem down in the third person, with your own name in it. Rather than “I don’t know if I should leave my job,” you’d write something like “John has been in this role six years and stopped learning in year four.” Kross has a separate study showing this works under pressure too. People who used their own name while getting ready for a stressful speech gave better speeches, as judged by independent raters, and brooded less afterward.
Then ask Grove’s question. If somebody competent took your seat tomorrow, what would they do in their first month? They wouldn’t have your sunk costs, your history with the people involved or any need to prove last year’s call was right, and that’s usually enough to make the answer obvious.
It also helps to push the clock out. There’s a line of research on what’s called temporal distancing, and the short version is that imagining how a stressful event will look years from now makes it less distressing today. People who do this by habit also report better well-being in general.
I’d add one warning, because the distance cuts both ways. Evan Polman has found that when we decide for other people we’re more optimistic and more inclined to act, and we expect things to go better than they probably will. That’s useful if you’re frozen and less useful if the decision can’t be undone. So let the advisor version of you make the call, and give the version of you who has to live with it one job, which is working out what it will cost and whether you can afford that. Reopening the decision isn’t part of that job.
If you want it to stick, do the diary. It takes ten minutes in the evening, written in the third person about whatever caused the most friction that day, every day for a month. That’s roughly what Grossmann’s participants did.
There are a few rules I’d hold to. Keep “I” out of the write-up, because once it creeps back in you’re thinking from inside the problem again. Write your own recommendation before you ask anyone else, or you’re handing them a call you’re perfectly able to make. Don’t decide anything big while you’re still worked up, and if you can’t write the third-person version calmly, take that as a sign you’re not ready. Once you’ve seen the problem clearly, switch back to “I” when you act. The distance is for working out what to do, and doing it and owning it is still on you.
A Simple Way to Keep Score
Make a list of every decision you have open at the moment and, next to each one, put the date you’d have told a friend to have it done by. However far today is past that date is what I’d call your Solomon tax. If this is working, those gaps start shrinking, and the things you’d tell a friend to sort out within a week get sorted out within a week.
Solomon was brilliant about everyone else’s problems. What he never had was a way to look at his own from the outside, and that part can be learned.
Sources
Grossmann, I., & Kross, E. (2014). Exploring Solomon’s paradox: Self-distancing eliminates the self-other asymmetry in wise reasoning about close relationships in younger and older adults. Psychological Science, 25(8), 1571–1580.
Grossmann, I., Dorfman, A., Oakes, H., Santos, H. C., Vohs, K. D., & Scholer, A. A. (2021). Training for wisdom: The distanced-self-reflection diary method. Psychological Science, 32(3), 381–394.
Kross, E., et al. (2014). Self-talk as a regulatory mechanism: How you do it matters. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 106(2), 304–324.
Bruehlman-Senecal, E., & Ayduk, O. (2015). This too shall pass: Temporal distance and the regulation of emotional distress. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 108(2), 356–375.
Polman, E., & Emich, K. J. (2011). Decisions for others are more creative than decisions for the self. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 37(4), 492–501.
Polman, E. (2018). Why it’s easier to make decisions for someone else. Harvard Business Review.
Grove, A. S. (1996). Only the Paranoid Survive. Currency Doubleday.



